Intermediate Court of Appeals Upholds Several Workers’ Compensation Board of Review Benzene Exposure Orders

Hartley Law Group has recently secured numerous workers’ compensation claim decisions for clients who developed cancer after exposure to benzene and/or other chemicals.

In the latest win, the Intermediate Court of Appeals decided the Workers’ Compensation Board of Review was correct in reversing a claim administrator’s order rejecting Michael Gardill’s occupational disease claim for follicular lymphoma, which is a type of non- Hodgkin’s lymphoma.

Mr. Gardill worked for Bayer US, LLC and its predecessor companies and was exposed to benzene.  He was diagnosed with follicular lymphoma in November 2021. Despite expert testimony that Mr. Gardill’s benzene exposure was a contributing factor to his lymphoma, a claim administrator for Sedgwick, a third-party administrator for Bayer, issued an order rejecting his claim for non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma, stating there was no causal connection between his cancer and employment. We protested this order to the Workers’ Compensation Board of Review.

On December 11, 2025, the Workers’ Compensation Board of Review reversed that order, finding we established that his occupational exposures to benzene were more likely a contributing factor to his cancer and ordering Bayer to pay the claim. Bayer appealed the order.

In its November 10, 2026 decision, the Intermediate Court of Appeals agreed with the Board of Review, upholding the decision to pay the claim.

Mark Ady

Mark Ady was diagnosed with renal cell carcinoma, Stage 3 chronic kidney disease and bladder carcinoma after working for Bayer.

Expert testimony linked Mr. Ady’s exposure to benzene, formaldehyde, ethylene oxide, toluene, TCE, trichloroethane, PERC, and Safety Kleen to his medical diagnoses. Despite this, a claim administrator for Sedgwick, a third-party administrator for Bayer, issued an order rejecting his claim, stating there was no causal connection between his cancer and employment. We protested this order to the Workers’ Compensation Board of Review.

On August 18, 2026, the Workers’ Compensation Board of Review reversed the order, finding the claim is held compensable.  The employer did not appeal the decision.

Dennis Thorn

Mr. Thorn worked for the West Virginia Department of Transportation for 36 years. During this time, he was exposed to numerous chemicals including, but not limited to paint, toluene, weed killer, diesel fuel and diesel exhaust fumes, gasoline and gasoline exhaust fumes, and aromatic hydrocarbon-containing products and/or chlorinated hydrocarbon-containing products. He later developed bladder and kidney cancer.

Expert testimony stated his chemical exposure during his employment with the WVDOT were contributing causes to cancer development. However, the claim administrator handling his claim denied it, opining his claim was untimely filed and that his injury was not a result of his employment with the WVDOT. We protested that order to the Workers’ Compensation Board of Review.

Not only did the Board find that Mr. Thorn’s claim was timely filed, it also found that we established his occupational exposures were more likely a contributing factor to his cancers and ordered the WVDOT to pay the claim. The WVDOT appealed the order.

On June 30, 2026, the Intermediate Court of Appeals upheld the claim reversal.

Jay Crofford

Jay Crofford also appealed a claim administrator’s order denying his worker compensation claim.

Mr. Crofford had filed an occupational disease claim alleging his development of chronic lymphocytic leukemia resulted from exposure to benzene during his employment at Koppers. The claim administrator denied the claim, opining his cancer was not work-related. We appealed to the Office of Judges, who reversed the order. That decision was later upheld by the Board of Review.

 

Douglas Steele

Mr. Steele worked for PPG Industries for 35 years as a chemical factory worker. During that time, he was exposed to benzene, 104 solvent, carbon tetrachloride, mineral spirits, aluminum cleaner, perchloroethylene, Safety-Kleen, hydrogen-sulfate, asbestos, caustic, barium, chlorine, ammonia, and liquid wrench. He was later diagnosed with chronic lymphocytic leukemia.

Experts reviewing his medical records and examining Mr. Steele personally, opined his cancer development was the result of benzene exposure. Despite this, the claims adjuster for PPG felt there was insufficient evidence to establish a causal connection and denied the claim.

We protested the decision to the Office of Judges, who ultimately reversed the claim adjuster’s decision after finding there was enough evidence to establish a connection between his cancer diagnosis and his benzene exposure. The Workers’ Compensation Board of Review affirmed that decision, and PPG appealed it to the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals.

The Supreme Court agreed with the Office of Judges and the Board, finding we submitted sufficient evidence that Mr. Steele’s benzene exposure while employed at PPG resulted in his development of chronic lymphocytic leukemia.

David Wells

Similarly, David Wells also worked for PPG Industries. During his 36 years of employment with them he was exposed to benzene. He later developed chronic myelomonocytic leukemia.

While an independent medical examination of Mr. Wells resulted in the opinion that his cancer was not linked to his benzene exposure, an expert in chemical exposure cases gave a verified statement, opining PPG violated many chemical safety rules and regulations. This created an unsafe working environment for Mr. Wells and directly led to his cancer diagnosis.

A claims adjuster for PPG denied the claim, again citing insufficient evidence. We protested the decision to the Office of Judges, who ultimately found we proved there is sufficient evidence to establish that benzene exposure causes chronic myelomonocytic leukemia and that Mr. Wells’s cancer was the result of his exposure to benzene.  The Workers’ Compensation Board of Review affirmed that decision, and PPG appealed it to the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals.

The Supreme Court agreed with the Office of Judges and the Board, finding we submitted sufficient evidence that Mr. Wells’ benzene exposure while employed at PPG resulted in his development of chronic myelomonocytic leukemia.

For more information on benzene exposure and its risks, read our blog on benzene exposure.

If you or a loved one was exposed to benzene during employment and developed cancer, Hartley Law Group is here to help you seek justice. We are here for our clients when they need us most. Send us a message online or call us at 1.304.233.0777 to schedule a consultation.




Related Posts: